Dom Problemów Fizycznych

Do mojego zakładu przyszedł email od dr. Temura Z. Kalanova z Uzbekistanu. Ma on bardzo ciekawą afiliację: Home of Physical Problems – Dom Problemów Fizycznych! Dr Kalanov prosi nas o opublikowanie (gdzie??) kilku jego prac poświęconych błędom logicznym w szczególnej teorii względności, termodynamice i innych teoriach. Proponuje w zamian własne, lepsze teorie, oparte na dialektyce (???) i logice formalnej, np. kwantową teorię stałej prędkości światła.

Nawet mój program pocztowy nie dał się na to nabrać:

Dear Professors,

I kindly ask you to publish my articles:

1) "The Correct Theoretical Analysis of the Foundations of the Special Theory of Relativity"
(Abstract:
The correct theoretical analysis of the generally accepted foundations
of the special theory of relativity is proposed. The principle of the
unity of formal logic and dialectics is a methodological basis of the
analysis. The main result is as follows: the foundations (i.e., the
interpretation of Michelson-Morley’s experimental data and
calculations, the contraction hypothesis and the Lorentz transformation
formulae, the concept of space-time, Einstein’s formula expressing
equivalence of mass and energy) contain logical errors and are not
consequence of any postulates. The existence of logical errors is
irrefutable proof of incorrectness of the special theory of relativity.
The following correct theories and principles are proposed: theory of
time; theory of space; the quantum theory of constancy of light speed;
the principle of equivalency of mass and energy; the principle of
objectivity of human knowledge; the theory of system of reference),

2) "The Correct Theoretical Analysis of the Foundations of Classical Thermodynamics"
(Abstract:
The correct theoretical analysis of the generally accepted foundations
of classical thermodynamics is proposed. The principle of the unity of
formal logic and rational dialectics is a methodological basis of the
analysis. The result is as follows: the foundations of classical
thermodynamics (i.e., the first and second laws, equation of state,
concepts of internal energy, of heat energy, of entropy, of
temperature) contain logical errors. The existence of logical errors is
irrefutable proof of incorrectness of thermodynamics. The correct
statistical foundations are proposed).

3) "The Correct Theory of Photon Gas"
(Abstract:
The correct theoretical analysis of the generally accepted foundations
of theory of photon (quantum) gas are proposed. The principle of the
unity of formal logic and of rational dialectics is the correct
methodological basis of the analysis. The new results – the correct
quantum-statistical foundations – obtained within the framework of the
formulated master equation taking into consideration both the quantum
states of the radiating molecule and the quantum states of the photon
gas in the isolated macroscopic systems “molecule + molecular gas +
monochromatic photon gas” are as follows: (a) Planck’s, Einstein’s, and
Bose’s works on the theory of photon (quantum) gas contain logical
errors; (b) photon (quantum) gas being born by radiating molecule obeys
“Gibbs statistics”: equilibrium photon (quantum) gas is described by
Gibbs quantum canonical distribution; (c) Planck function (“Bose’s
distribution”) is an consequence of Gibbs quantum canonical
distribution; (d) Einstein coefficients (i.e. the coefficients of
spontaneous emission, induced emission and absorption) are equal to
each other).

4) "CRISIS IN THEORETICAL PHYSICS: THE PROBLEM OF SCIENTIFIC TRUTH"
(Abstract:
The problem of truth in science – the most urgent problem of our time
– is discussed. The correct theoretical analysis of the generally
accepted foundations of theoretical physics is proposed. The principle
of the unity of formal logic and rational dialectics is a
methodological basis of the analysis. The main result is as follows:
the foundations (i.e. classical thermodynamics, the special theory of
relativity, quantum mechanics) contain logical errors The existence of
logical errors is irrefutable proof of incorrectness of the theoretical
foundations and means that theoretical physics enters the greatest
crisis. The crisis in physics leads inevitably to the general crisis in
science. The crisis as effect is explained by existence of the global
cause: the crisis is a collateral and inevitable result of inductive
method of knowledge of the Nature).

Sincerely yours,
Dr. Temur Z. Kalanov

Home of Physical Problems,
Pisatelskaya 6a, 700200 Taskent, UzbekistanTel. +(998 712) 142 14 35
E-mail:
tzk_uz@yahoo.com,
t.z.kalanov@mail.ru,
t.z.kalanov@rambler.ru

Co ciekawe, na wyzwanie Kalanova odpowiedzieli niektórzy fizycy:

Prof. Gerard ‚t Hooft: May 15, 2006

Even if you don’t like its logic, the Special (and the General) Theory of Relativity works remarkably well.
The only changes you can bring about is in the names you attach to things. I don’t care much about that.

Skomentuj

Wprowadź swoje dane lub kliknij jedną z tych ikon, aby się zalogować:

Logo WordPress.com

Komentujesz korzystając z konta WordPress.com. Wyloguj /  Zmień )

Zdjęcie na Google

Komentujesz korzystając z konta Google. Wyloguj /  Zmień )

Zdjęcie z Twittera

Komentujesz korzystając z konta Twitter. Wyloguj /  Zmień )

Zdjęcie na Facebooku

Komentujesz korzystając z konta Facebook. Wyloguj /  Zmień )

Połączenie z %s